Google Maps vs OpenStreetMap: Which One Should You Use?

DateAuthorBranko NovakReading time4 min
Google Maps vs OpenStreetMap: Which One Should You Use?

Almost every website or app that shows locations has to choose a map. Google Maps is the familiar choice, while OpenStreetMap is the open alternative used by many apps and companies around the world.

In this article we compare data, features, APIs, costs and licensing, so you can decide which one fits your project.

Google Maps in short

Google Maps launched in 2005 and is now the most widely used map service in the world. For developers it is part of Google Maps Platform, which offers maps, routes, places, geocoding and Street View through well-documented APIs.

Strengths: excellent coverage, detailed business and place data, accurate routing with live traffic, Street View and a design users already know.

Weaknesses: the data is closed and cannot be edited or reused freely, usage beyond the free allowance is billed per request, and the terms of service limit how the data can be stored and displayed.

OpenStreetMap in short

OpenStreetMap (OSM) started in 2004 as a community project, often described as the Wikipedia of maps. Volunteers, companies and public institutions maintain map data for the whole world, and anyone can use it under the Open Database License, as long as OpenStreetMap is credited.

Strengths: open data that you can download, edit, store and style as you wish, no per-request fees for the data itself, excellent detail in many cities and full support for offline use.

Weaknesses: coverage of businesses and points of interest varies by region, there is no official Street View, and for production use you need your own servers or a commercial provider for map tiles, search and routing.

Routing and directions

Google Maps calculates routes and travel times for driving, walking, cycling and public transport, with live traffic. For OSM there are mature open-source routing engines such as OSRM, GraphHopper and Valhalla, which can be self-hosted or used through providers.

Design and customization

Google Maps can be styled through the Maps Platform. OpenStreetMap goes further: because you control the data, you can design maps completely in your brand style, using vector tiles from providers like Mapbox, MapTiler or Stadia Maps, or your own tile server.

Costs

Google Maps Platform includes a free monthly usage allowance, after which you pay per request. For small sites this is often free, but costs can grow quickly with traffic. OpenStreetMap data is free, but you pay for hosting or for a tile and API provider, which is usually cheaper at scale.

Which one should you choose?

  • Google Maps is the best choice when you need accurate business data, live traffic, Street View or the experience users already know, and the expected usage fits your budget.
  • OpenStreetMap is the best choice when you need full control over data and design, offline maps, large traffic at predictable costs or the freedom to store and process map data.
  • A combination often works best: OSM-based maps for display and Google services only where their data is essential.

Maps and your local visibility

If you run a local business, being visible on maps is just as important as the map on your website. Keep your Google Business Profile and Bing Places listings accurate, and if you need a custom map feature in your website or app, our web app development team can help.